A good backcountry pack horse or mule can make a long day in the mountains a whole lot easier. A poor one can turn an otherwise routine trip into hours of frustration, and sometimes a dangerous situation. When you’re miles from the trailhead with a string of loaded animals behind you, having dependable stock makes a tremendous difference.
Over the years I spent packing and guiding in Idaho’s backcountry, I worked with horses and mules of different ages, sizes, and temperaments. Some became outstanding pack animals, while others never quite developed into the kind of stock I wanted to depend on.
One thing I learned is that a good pack animal isn’t necessarily the biggest, strongest, or best-looking horse or mule in the bunch. There are other qualities that matter a great deal more.
Temperament Comes First
If I were looking at a horse or mule for backcountry packing, temperament would be one of the first things I’d consider.
I want an animal that’s calm, willing to work, and reasonably easy to handle. It doesn’t have to be perfect, but it needs to have a good disposition. An animal that’s constantly nervous, aggressive, or difficult to control creates problems for everyone working around it.
A good pack animal should stand quietly while being saddled and loaded. It should lead willingly, follow the animal ahead of it, and handle ordinary activities around camp without becoming unnecessarily excited.
That doesn’t mean a young animal won’t occasionally get nervous. A green horse or mule may react to unfamiliar equipment, a shifting load, or something it hasn’t encountered before. What matters is whether it learns from those experiences and becomes more dependable with time.
There’s a difference between an inexperienced animal that needs more work and one with dangerous habits that you may never be able to trust.
Soundness and Physical Condition
Temperament is important, but the animal also has to be physically capable of doing the job.
Backcountry packing can involve long climbs, steep descents, rocky trails, creek crossings, and hours of traveling with a load. An animal that isn’t physically suited to that work may have difficulty holding up through an entire season.
I pay particular attention to the feet and legs. Good feet, sound legs, and the ability to travel comfortably over rough country are essential. A horse or mule with chronic lameness or serious hoof problems isn’t something I’d want to take miles into the mountains.
The back is another important consideration. A pack saddle needs to fit properly, and the animal must be capable of carrying a balanced load without developing soreness.
Size alone doesn’t tell you whether an animal will make a good packer. I’d rather have a sound, well-built animal of moderate size than a large animal with poor feet, weak conformation, or a troublesome disposition.
Surefootedness and Trail Sense
One of the qualities I appreciate most in good mountain stock is the ability to negotiate difficult country without constantly needing direction.
A dependable animal learns to watch its footing, step carefully over obstacles, and move through narrow or uneven places without becoming overly excited.
This becomes especially important when traveling with a loaded pack string. A poor decision by one animal can affect the animals behind it, particularly on steep or confined trails.
I’ve noticed that mules often seem quite deliberate about where they place their feet. They may also be cautious when approaching something unfamiliar. That caution isn’t necessarily a bad thing, especially when the animal is evaluating an obstacle rather than blindly rushing into it.
Horses can also become excellent mountain pack animals. Much depends on the individual animal, its training, and the experience it has gained.
A Good Pack Animal Learns From Experience
There’s a noticeable difference between a green animal and one that’s spent several seasons working in the mountains.
Experienced stock become familiar with the daily routine. They learn what’s expected when being caught, saddled, loaded, tied, and led down the trail.
They also become more accustomed to the sights and sounds of packing. Equipment rattling, packs shifting slightly, branches brushing against a load, and other ordinary occurrences generally become less concerning as the animal gains experience.
I’ve seen an interesting difference between horses and mules when it comes to protecting their loads.
A mule might bump its pack against a tree once and seem to remember the experience. Afterward, it often makes an effort to give trees and other obstacles enough clearance. Some horses I’ve worked with would bump the same kind of obstacle repeatedly without making much adjustment.
That doesn’t mean every mule is smarter than every horse. It’s simply something I’ve observed while working with both.
Experience can also improve an animal’s judgment about how to travel with a load. A seasoned pack animal often requires less attention, allowing the packer to concentrate on the rest of the string.
Willingness to Work
A good pack horse or mule should be willing to do its job without constantly being encouraged.
I like an animal that maintains a steady pace, follows willingly, and continues working when the trail becomes difficult. It shouldn’t repeatedly stop, pull back, or look for ways to avoid leaving camp.
A dependable animal also needs to cooperate during the less exciting parts of the day. Standing quietly while loads are adjusted, waiting during stops, and being handled repeatedly are all part of the job.
That willingness doesn’t mean an animal should be pushed beyond its physical capabilities. Even good stock can become sore or overworked. The packer needs to recognize when something isn’t right.
An animal that’s willing to work, physically capable, and sensible about how it travels is worth keeping.
How an Animal Fits Into the Pack String
Not every horse or mule works equally well in every position in a pack string.
Some animals get along better with certain companions. Others tend to crowd the animal ahead of them, pull back, or create problems when placed in the wrong position.
I generally liked to establish an order that worked and keep it fairly consistent. Experienced, dependable animals can help maintain a steady string, while troublesome animals may require a different arrangement.
For example, if I had an animal inclined to kick, I would generally put it toward the rear rather than have it kicking at the animals following behind.
I also preferred placing young, green animals near the front, where I could lead them directly. I found an inexperienced animal easier to control when I was the one leading it.
These are the kinds of adjustments that come from learning the individual animals. A pack string works best when the packer understands the habits and personalities of the stock being used.
Conditioning for Mountain Work
Even a good pack animal needs to be physically prepared for the season.
I wouldn’t expect an animal that’s been standing around for months to immediately handle long days carrying heavy loads through steep country.
Conditioning should be built gradually. Regular work, increasing distances, hill climbing, and progressively heavier loads help prepare the animal for more demanding trips.
It’s also important to check feet, shoes, backs, and general condition before the season begins.
Different animals require different amounts of preparation. Age, previous experience, and physical condition all influence how quickly an animal can be brought into working shape.
During the season, watch for soreness, unusual fatigue, and changes in behavior. A normally dependable animal that suddenly begins acting differently may be trying to tell you something.
Before assuming it’s simply being difficult, check the load, saddle, feet, and surrounding conditions. Sometimes the problem isn’t the animal’s attitude at all.
What to Look for When Buying a Pack Horse or Mule
Buying an animal for backcountry packing deserves more consideration than simply looking at its appearance or taking the seller’s word for how well it works.
I’d want to see the animal caught, haltered, led, saddled, and loaded. I’d also want to inspect its physical condition and observe how it behaves around other horses and mules.
Ask about its age, training, previous work, and any known problems. Then pay attention to whether the animal’s behavior matches what you’re being told.
There are certain warning signs I wouldn’t overlook. Serious lameness, aggressive behavior, dangerous pulling back, bucking, or extreme nervousness can all create major problems in the backcountry.
I’d also be cautious of a seller who seems unwilling to answer questions or demonstrate what the animal can do.
For someone just getting started, I’d recommend buying a dependable, experienced animal rather than taking on a young, untrained one. If you don’t have much experience evaluating horses or mules, bring along someone who does.
A cheap animal with dangerous habits can become an expensive mistake.
The Animals You Learn to Depend On
After working with an animal through a season or two, you begin to know what to expect from it.
You learn how it handles difficult trails, how it behaves around other stock, and whether it can be trusted to do its job without constant attention.
The best pack animals aren’t always the ones that stand out when you first look at them. They’re the ones that consistently do their work, stay out of trouble, and make the day’s packing easier rather than harder.
A dependable horse or mule is developed through good handling, proper training, conditioning, and experience. Choosing an animal with the right qualities gives you a much better starting point.
When you’re a long way from camp and still have several miles of mountain trail ahead, that’s the kind of animal you appreciate having in your string.
