One of the most valuable lessons I’ve learned hunting elk in Idaho’s mountains is that getting ahead of them can be far more productive than trying to catch up.
I remember guiding a hunter who was getting impatient. We had located a bull with his cows, and the elk were moving out of the area. The hunter wanted to move faster than I thought we should, and eventually he decided to go his own way.
I had a pretty good idea where those elk were headed, so instead of chasing after them, I worked toward the route I figured they’d take.
Before long, I was standing about thirty yards from a six-point bull, broadside. He was taking his cows out of the country, and I’d managed to put myself right where they were going. Unfortunately, the hunter wasn’t there to take advantage of the opportunity.
That hunt illustrates something I’ve learned over the years. When elk are on the move, sometimes it’s better to figure out where they’re going than to follow where they’ve already been.
Learn to Read Where Elk Are Going
One of the first things I try to determine when I locate elk is what they’re doing. Are they feeding, moving toward bedding cover, or traveling steadily through the country? Their behavior often tells me more about the opportunity than the distance separating us.
A herd that’s feeding slowly may give you time to work into position. Elk that are traveling with a purpose are a different matter. Trying to follow them through steep, timbered country can turn into a long day of covering ground without ever getting close.
Instead of concentrating entirely on the elk, I start looking at the country ahead of them.
Mountain terrain naturally influences how animals travel. Saddles, benches, finger ridges, and timbered routes can offer easier ways through steep country. Elk don’t always follow the route you expect, but knowing the terrain can help you narrow down where they’re likely to go.
That’s where experience becomes valuable. After spending enough time in an area, you begin recognizing the routes elk use and the places where you might have an opportunity to intercept them.
You don’t have to know exactly where they’re going. You just need to recognize when the country offers a better opportunity ahead of them than behind them.
Don’t Confuse Movement With Progress
There’s something about spotting a good bull that makes a hunter want to get moving. I understand that feeling. But just because you’re covering ground doesn’t mean you’re getting any closer to a shooting opportunity.
I’ve seen elk across drainages that looked reasonably close through binoculars. Getting to them, however, meant dropping down a steep mountainside, crossing the bottom, and climbing back up the other side.
That can take considerably longer than it appears.
Meanwhile, the elk may be steadily moving away. By the time you reach the spot where you originally saw them, they’re somewhere else entirely. You can spend the rest of the day trying to catch up with animals that have no reason to wait for you.
Before committing to a long stalk, I want to know whether the elk are likely to remain in the area. If they’re moving steadily, I look for another approach that might put me ahead of them. If I can’t find one, I may decide they’re simply not worth chasing.
That can be a difficult decision when you’re looking at a good bull, but there are times when walking away gives you a better chance of finding another opportunity.
Let the Terrain Work for You
One advantage of hunting mountainous country is that the terrain can sometimes help you get into position without following directly behind the elk.
Suppose you spot a herd feeding along a timbered slope. They’re gradually working toward a saddle that connects two ridges. If the wind is favorable and you can reach that saddle without exposing yourself, you may have an opportunity to let the elk come to you.
That’s a very different approach from trying to close the distance every time the animals move.
The same principle applies in thick timber. Elk may be traveling along a bench or working through a particular draw. If you understand the country and have a reasonable idea where they’re headed, moving into a good position and waiting can be more productive than following their tracks.
Of course, there’s no guarantee they’ll take the route you expect. Elk can change direction without giving you any warning, and sometimes they’ll do something entirely different from what you anticipated.
But I’d rather make a calculated decision based on the terrain and their direction of travel than spend hours blindly following them.
The Wind Still Has the Final Say
Even when you’ve figured out a likely route, the wind can ruin the entire plan.
Mountain winds can be unpredictable. Air currents move through draws, around ridges, and up or down slopes as conditions change. An approach that looks good from a distance may become impractical once you get into the timber.
I’ve had plenty of situations where the wind forced me to reconsider what I was doing. Sometimes that meant stopping and waiting. Other times, it meant backing out and finding another way around.
There’s no single answer that works every time.
What matters is recognizing when the conditions have changed enough that your original plan no longer makes sense. If the wind is carrying your scent toward the elk, continuing along the same route may only alert them before you ever get close.
The goal isn’t simply to get ahead of the elk. It’s to get there without letting them know you’re coming.
Know When to Leave Them Alone
Not every herd presents an opportunity worth pursuing.
If the elk are moving too quickly, the terrain doesn’t offer a practical way to get ahead, or the wind makes an approach nearly impossible, I don’t see much value in chasing them simply because I’ve located them.
Time of day can also influence the decision. If I spot elk late in the afternoon and reaching them would require an hour and a half or more of hard traveling, I may decide to wait until the following morning.
That doesn’t mean giving up on those elk. It means recognizing that the opportunity may be better under different circumstances.
There are also times when the best decision is to remain exactly where you are. If elk are already working toward your position and you’ve got good cover and favorable wind, moving closer may accomplish nothing except increasing your chances of being detected.
Patience isn’t about being afraid to make a move. It’s about knowing whether that move will actually improve your position.
Think Before You Take the First Step
The longer I hunted and guided in Idaho’s backcountry, the more I came to appreciate the importance of thinking through a situation before committing to it.
That doesn’t mean standing around trying to predict every move an elk might make. There are times when you have to act quickly, and hesitation can cost you an opportunity just as easily as impatience.
But when I locate elk, I want to understand what they’re doing, where they’re likely headed, and whether the country gives me a realistic way to get into position.
I think back to that six-point bull standing thirty yards away. I hadn’t outrun those elk or followed them step for step. I’d simply looked at where they were going and put myself along their route.
The hunter who went his own way missed that opportunity. It was a good reminder of how much difference one decision can make.
You don’t always have to move faster than the elk. Sometimes you just have to think a little farther ahead.
